20 Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes [2024]

Are you looking for the best old bay seasoning substitutes? Based on expert reviews, we ranked them. We've listed our top-ranked picks, including the top-selling old bay seasoning substitutes.

We Recommended:

# Preview Product
1 OLD BAY Seasoning, 24 oz - One 24 Ounce Container of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning with Unique Blend... OLD BAY Seasoning, 24 oz - One 24 Ounce Container of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning with Unique...
2 OLD BAY Seasoning, 16 oz - One 16 Ounce Fan-Favorite Tin Can of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning with... OLD BAY Seasoning, 16 oz - One 16 Ounce Fan-Favorite Tin Can of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning...
3 Old Bay Seasoning, For Seafood, Poultry, Salads, and Meats, 2.62 Oz Old Bay Seasoning, For Seafood, Poultry, Salads, and Meats, 2.62 Oz
4 Old Bay Crab Cake Classic Crab Cake Mix, 1.24-Ounce Packets (Pack of 12) Old Bay Crab Cake Classic Crab Cake Mix, 1.24-Ounce Packets (Pack of 12)
5 OLD BAY Seasoning, 6 oz OLD BAY Seasoning, 6 oz
6 OLD BAY Crab Cake Classic Seasoning Mix, 5 lb - One 5 Pound Container of Crab Cake Seasoning with... OLD BAY Crab Cake Classic Seasoning Mix, 5 lb - One 5 Pound Container of Crab Cake Seasoning with...
7 Old Bay Seasoning Hot, 2.5 oz Old Bay Seasoning Hot, 2.5 oz
8 The Red Chile Bible: Southwestern Classic & Gourmet Recipes The Red Chile Bible: Southwestern Classic & Gourmet Recipes
9 Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Lemon Pepper, 2.5 Ounce Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Lemon Pepper, 2.5 Ounce
10 ZATARAINS Crab and Shrimp Boil Liquid, Concentrated, 8-Ounce ZATARAINS Crab and Shrimp Boil Liquid, Concentrated, 8-Ounce
11 Phillips Blackening Seasoning used in Phillips Seafood Restaurants on Blackened Chicken, Fish &... Phillips Blackening Seasoning used in Phillips Seafood Restaurants on Blackened Chicken, Fish &...
12 Bragg, All Purpose Seasonings, 1.5 oz Bragg, All Purpose Seasonings, 1.5 oz
13 Zatarain's New Orleans Style Blackened Seasoning, 3 oz Zatarain's New Orleans Style Blackened Seasoning, 3 oz
14 McCormick Shrimp and Crab Boil Seasoning, 3 oz McCormick Shrimp and Crab Boil Seasoning, 3 oz
15 Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Table Blend, 2.5 Ounce Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Table Blend, 2.5 Ounce
16 The Spice Lab - Chopped Dried Green Chives / Dehydrated - All Natural Kosher Non GMO Gluten Free... The Spice Lab - Chopped Dried Green Chives / Dehydrated - All Natural Kosher Non GMO Gluten Free...
17 Chef Paul Prudhomme's Magic Seasoning Blends ~ Blackened Redfish Magic, 2-Ounce Bottle Chef Paul Prudhomme's Magic Seasoning Blends ~ Blackened Redfish Magic, 2-Ounce Bottle
18 Naturevibe Botanicals Organic Asafetida Powder 100gm (Hing, Asafoetida Ground) 3.53oz | Non-GMO and... Naturevibe Botanicals Organic Asafetida Powder 100gm (Hing, Asafoetida Ground) 3.53oz | Non-GMO...
19 BIGS Takis Fuego Sunflower Seeds, Hot Chili Lime Flavor, Keto Friendly Snack, 5.35 oz. (Pack of 8) BIGS Takis Fuego Sunflower Seeds, Hot Chili Lime Flavor, Keto Friendly Snack, 5.35 oz. (Pack of 8)
20 16oz Ajinomoto Umami Seasoning, MSG Monosodium Glutamate, Made in USA, Naturally Delicious (One Bag... 16oz Ajinomoto Umami Seasoning, MSG Monosodium Glutamate, Made in USA, Naturally Delicious (One...
Bestseller No. 1
OLD BAY Seasoning, 24 oz - One 24 Ounce Container of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning with Unique Blend...
  • WORLD FAMOUS TASTE: OLD BAY Seafood Seasoning has a distinct, world-famous taste that elevates any recipe; bring authentic New England flavors...
  • UNIQUE BLEND: Features a unique blend of 18 spices and herbs, such as red and black pepper, celery salt and paprika for a bold seasoning you can enjoy...
  • DESIGNED FOR FOOD SERVICE: Comes in a 24-ounce container for easy back-of-house recipe customization in fast-paced and high-volume settings
  • VERSATILE SEASONING: Born in the heart of the Chesapeake Bay area, OLD BAY is an all-purpose seasoning perfect for seafood, poultry or snacks like...
  • FEEL GOOD INGREDIENTS: Kosher seasoning with no added MSG, ideal for sprinkling on various menu items like pizza and chowder
Bestseller No. 2
OLD BAY Seasoning, 16 oz - One 16 Ounce Fan-Favorite Tin Can of OLD BAY All-Purpose Seasoning with...
  • WORLD FAMOUS TASTE: OLD BAY Seafood Seasoning has a distinct, world-famous taste that elevates any recipe; bring authentic New England flavors...
  • UNIQUE BLEND: Features a unique blend of 18 spices and herbs, such as red and black pepper, celery salt and paprika for a bold seasoning you can enjoy...
  • FAN-FAVORITE CAN: Comes in the 16-ounce iconic tin can for true OLD BAY fans
  • VERSATILE SEASONING: Born in the heart of the Chesapeake Bay area, OLD BAY is an all-purpose seasoning perfect for seafood, poultry or snacks like...
  • FEEL GOOD INGREDIENTS: Kosher seasoning with no added MSG, ideal for sprinkling on various menu items like pizza and chowder
Bestseller No. 3
Old Bay Seasoning, For Seafood, Poultry, Salads, and Meats, 2.62 Oz
  • Savory blend of herbs and spices including McCormick celery salt, paprika and red and black peppers for the culinary enthusiast
  • Kosher, no MSG added, no hydrogenated oil
  • Easy to shake, sprinkle and pour
  • Recipe Tip: To liven up your favorite seafood dish, just add 2 tbsp. of our old bay Seasoning for every 1 lb. of fish
  • FUN FACT: Since 1939, OLD BAY has been spicing up chicken, seafood, snacks and more
Bestseller No. 4
Old Bay Crab Cake Classic Crab Cake Mix, 1.24-Ounce Packets (Pack of 12)
  • Member of the world-famous OLD BAY Seasoning flavor family
  • Just add crab meat and mayonnaise to make authentic Maryland crab cakes
  • Authentic seasoning mix for crab cakes with a touch of OLD BAY
  • Blend features OLD BAY, herbs and spices and bread crumbs
Bestseller No. 5
OLD BAY Seasoning, 6 oz
  • Savory blend of herbs and spices including McCormick celery salt, paprika and red and black peppers for the culinary enthusiast
  • Kosher, no MSG added, no hydrogenated oil
  • BPA-free package is easy to shake, sprinkle and pour
  • Recipe Tip: To liven up your favorite seafood dish, just add 2 tbsp. of our OLD BAY Seasoning for every 1 lb. of fish
  • FUN FACT: Since 1939, OLD BAY has been spicing up chicken, seafood, snacks and more
Bestseller No. 6
OLD BAY Crab Cake Classic Seasoning Mix, 5 lb - One 5 Pound Container of Crab Cake Seasoning with...
  • OLD BAY Crab Cake Classic Seasoning Mix takes seafood dishes to the next level with its stunning, one-of-a-kind flavor profile
  • Features a familiar combination of spices, herbs and bread crumbs to create the distinct taste customers crave
  • Contains 5 pounds of crab cake seasoning, offering enough to prepare up to 40 pounds of crab meat
  • Pairs well with classic crab cake recipes as well as chicken and veggie dishes
  • Blended without added MSG for the world-famous seafood seasoning you know and trust
Bestseller No. 7
Old Bay Seasoning Hot, 2.5 oz
  • For Seafood, Chicken, Salads, Meats and More...; Wags Crabs Shrimp
  • spices-and-seasonings
Bestseller No. 8
The Red Chile Bible: Southwestern Classic & Gourmet Recipes
  • New
  • Mint Condition
  • Dispatch same day for order received before 12 noon
  • Guaranteed packaging
  • No quibbles returns
Bestseller No. 9
Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Lemon Pepper, 2.5 Ounce
  • This favorite Bear Creek soup tastes like it simmered for hours- not minutes.
  • This hearty soup is chock-full of pasta and delicious veggies simmered in a rich beef stock.
  • Try adding cooked ground beef and diced tomatoes for variety.
  • Easy to prepare mix, just add water.
  • Bring home a little comfort
Bestseller No. 10
ZATARAINS Crab and Shrimp Boil Liquid, Concentrated, 8-Ounce
  • The package length of the product is 3.8 inches
  • The package width of the product is 2.3 inches
  • The package height of the product is 2.2 inches
  • Country of origin is United States
SaleBestseller No. 11
Phillips Blackening Seasoning used in Phillips Seafood Restaurants on Blackened Chicken, Fish &...
  • Blend of Authentic Spices and Herbs that gives any food a boost. Not as spicy as Cajun seasoning but spicier than Creole seasoning.
  • Blackening Spice is used at Phillips Seafood Restaurant locations nationwide since 1956.
  • Blackened Seasoning is perfect for all seafood (see below for complete list).
  • Used in literally hundreds of dishes to provide a little “zing” of flavor.
  • Great healthy substitute for salt and pepper or other herbs and spices called for in recipes.
SaleBestseller No. 12
Bragg, All Purpose Seasonings, 1.5 oz
  • Bragg Organic Sprinkle is an original blend of 24 organic herbs and spices. Contains no additives, no preservatives, no fillers.
  • A blend of All Natural Herbs and Spices
  • Gluten Free.
Bestseller No. 13
Zatarain's New Orleans Style Blackened Seasoning, 3 oz
  • New Orleans classic Blackened Seasoning
  • For best results, cook meat in the broiler or on the grill
  • Unique blend of spices like red pepper, paprika and garlic
  • Perfect to jazz up pork, chicken, fish or steak
  • Use just 1/4 teaspoon per serving to create bold blackened flavor
SaleBestseller No. 14
McCormick Shrimp and Crab Boil Seasoning, 3 oz
  • The distinctive, southern-style flavor comes from dill, pepper and other seasonings
Bestseller No. 15
Dash Salt-Free Seasoning Blend, Table Blend, 2.5 Ounce
  • Dash table seasoning blend
  • Proprietary blend of herbs and spices including cayenne pepper, coriander, garlic and orange peel
  • Savory with a hint of spicy citrus
  • No preservatives, artificial colors, or flavors added
  • Kosher
Bestseller No. 16
The Spice Lab - Chopped Dried Green Chives / Dehydrated - All Natural Kosher Non GMO Gluten Free...
  • ORIGIN: Chives have a wide variety of culinary uses, such as in traditional dishes in France, Sweden, and elsewhere.
  • USE: Chives are used with soups, fish, and sandwiches.
  • HISTORY: Chives are one of the fines herbes of French cuisine, which also include tarragon, chervil, or parsley.
  • FLAVOR: The delicate flavor that chives impart to food makes it a very useful herb to use in a variety of situations .
  • HEALTH: Chives are also rich in vitamins A and C, and are rich in calcium and iron.
Bestseller No. 17
Chef Paul Prudhomme's Magic Seasoning Blends ~ Blackened Redfish Magic, 2-Ounce Bottle
  • Use Blackened Redfish Magic to give great flavor to blackened, bronzed, fried, baked, broiled, sautéed or boiled shrimp, crab, crawfish, oysters,...
  • Easy to use in gumbos, soups, sauces & dressing.
  • Substitute for normal use of salt, pepper and other herbs & spices called for in a recipe.
  • Magic Seasonings are versatile in their application and pack incredible depth of flavor.
  • All natural, contains no MSG or preservatives and is Kosher approved.
Bestseller No. 18
Naturevibe Botanicals Organic Asafetida Powder 100gm (Hing, Asafoetida Ground) 3.53oz | Non-GMO and...
  • Asafoetida is the dried latex (gum oleoresin) exuded from the living underground rhizome or tap root of several species of Ferula (three of which grow...
  • Asafetida odour and flavour become much milder and much less pungent upon heating in oil or ghee. Sometimes, it is fried along with sautéed onion and...
  • Many commercial preparations of asafoetida use the resin ground up and mixed with a larger volume of other neutral ingredients, such as gum arabic,...
  • Asafoetida is extensively used for flavouring curries, sauces, and pickles.
  • It has a prominent place in traditional medicine; thanks to its carminative properties. Considering its therapeutic and curative powers, asafoetida is...
Bestseller No. 19
BIGS Takis Fuego Sunflower Seeds, Hot Chili Lime Flavor, Keto Friendly Snack, 5.35 oz. (Pack of 8)
  • Contains eight 5.35-ounce bags of BIGS Takis Fuego Sunflower Seeds, Hot Chili Lime Flavor
  • Dig into a bag of crunchy, spicy goodness with BIGS seeds seasoned with Takis Fuego Hot Chili & Lime flavor
  • Indulge in keto friendly, salty snacks that fit a low carb lifestyle - 7g of Protein, 2g Net Carbs (4g Total Carbs minus 2g Dietary Fiber), and 0g...
  • Handy resealable bag is perfect for road trips, ball games or anytime snacking
  • Stock up on big seeds and big flavor
SaleBestseller No. 20
16oz Ajinomoto Umami Seasoning, MSG Monosodium Glutamate, Made in USA, Naturally Delicious (One Bag...
  • One - 16oz Bag per order
  • Ajinomoto is a seasoning that enhances Umami taste of all your dishes.
  • Made from corn glucose in America's heartland.

Having trouble finding a great old bay seasoning substitutes?

This problem is well understood by us because we have gone through the entire old bay seasoning substitutes research process ourselves, which is why we have put together a comprehensive list of the best old bay seasoning substitutess available in the market today.

After hours of searching and using all the models on the market, we have found the best old bay seasoning substitutes for 2023. See our ranking below!

How Do You Buy The Best Old Bay Seasoning Substitutes?

Do you get stressed out thinking about shopping for a great old bay seasoning substitutes? Do doubts keep creeping into your mind?

We understand, because we’ve already gone through the whole process of researching old bay seasoning substitutes, which is why we have assembled a comprehensive list of the greatest old bay seasoning substitutes available in the current market. We’ve also come up with a list of questions that you probably have yourself.

John Harvards has done the best we can with our thoughts and recommendations, but it’s still crucial that you do thorough research on your own for old bay seasoning substitutes that you consider buying. Your questions might include the following:

  • Is it worth buying an old bay seasoning substitutes?
  • What benefits are there with buying an old bay seasoning substitutes?
  • What factors deserve consideration when shopping for an effective old bay seasoning substitutes?
  • Why is it crucial to invest in any old bay seasoning substitutes, much less the best one?
  • Which old bay seasoning substitutes are good in the current market?
  • Where can you find information like this about old bay seasoning substitutes?

We’re convinced that you likely have far more questions than just these regarding old bay seasoning substitutes, and the only real way to satisfy your need for knowledge is to get information from as many reputable online sources as you possibly can.

Potential sources can include buying guides for old bay seasoning substitutes, rating websites, word-of-mouth testimonials, online forums, and product reviews. Thorough and mindful research is crucial to making sure you get your hands on the best-possible old bay seasoning substitutes. Make sure that you are only using trustworthy and credible websites and sources.

John Harvards provides an old bay seasoning substitutes buying guide, and the information is totally objective and authentic. We employ both AI and big data in proofreading the collected information.

How did we create this buying guide? We did it using a custom-created selection of algorithms that lets us manifest a top-10 list of the best available old bay seasoning substitutes currently available on the market.

This technology we use to assemble our list depends on a variety of factors, including but not limited to the following:

  1. Brand Value: Every brand of old bay seasoning substitutes has a value all its own. Most brands offer some sort of unique selling proposition that’s supposed to bring something different to the table than their competitors.
  2. Features: What bells and whistles matter for an old bay seasoning substitutes?
  3. Specifications: How powerful they are can be measured.
  4. Product Value: This simply is how much bang for the buck you get from your old bay seasoning substitutes.
  5. Customer Ratings: Number ratings grade old bay seasoning substitutes objectively.
  6. Customer Reviews: Closely related to ratings, these paragraphs give you first-hand and detailed information from real-world users about their old bay seasoning substitutes.
  7. Product Quality: You don’t always get what you pay for with an old bay seasoning substitutes, sometimes less, and sometimes more.
  8. Product Reliability: How sturdy and durable an old bay seasoning substitutes is should be an indication of how long it will work out for you.

John Harvards always remembers that maintaining old bay seasoning substitutes information to stay current is a top priority, which is why we are constantly updating our websites. Learn more about us using online sources.

If you think that anything we present here regarding old bay seasoning substitutes is irrelevant, incorrect, misleading, or erroneous, then please let us know promptly!

Related Post:

FAQ:

Q: How do you make homemade Old Bay Seasoning?

A: Steam seafood in Old Bay. Dump your seasoning into a pot of boiling water,and then add shrimp,crabs,or other seafood. Serve a combination of Old Bay and vinegar to use as a dip. … Fry meat or seafood with an Old Bay coating. … Mix Old Bay into soups and stews. … Spruce up your snacks with Old Bay. … Add Old Bay to a Bloody Mary. …

Q: How to make Old Bay seasoning mix?

A: Gather the ingredients. The Spruce/Victoria Heydt Combine all ingredients in a mixing bowl and mix thoroughly. The Spruce/Victoria Heydt Store in an airtight container in a cool,dry,dark place. Use in your favorite recipes and enjoy. The Spruce/Victoria Heydt

Q: Is old Bay the only crab boil seasoning?

A: October 1, 2023. October 1, 2023. / By Tammie McKeown. For many people the only two crab seasonings are Old Bay and J.O. but Zatarain’s crab boil is actually quite a tasty alternative. It’s also quite a bit cheaper than the alternatives, granted you need to order a 4.5 lb jar in order to achieve those savings.

Q: What does Old Bay Seasoning taste like?

A: Crab boil. Pickling spice. Cajun seasoning. Todd’s Dirt. Seasoned salt. Chinese five spice. Copycat Old Bay Seasoning.